What causes roof leaks, and how they're fixed

What causes roof leaks on Auckland homes, and how they're fixed: lead-head nails, rust under flashings, pipe flashings, and cracked tiles and bedding.

What causes roof leaks, and how they're fixed

A stain on the ceiling after a storm, a drip in the hallway, a damp patch that comes and goes. Most roof leaks start small, and most of them come from a short list of places.

This post covers the most common causes of roof leaks we find on the roofs we work on across Auckland, why they happen, how they're fixed, and when a repair is still worth doing.

Short answer: on older metal roofs, most leaks come from the fixings and flashings: lead-head nails working loose, rust under the ridge and other flashings, and failed pipe flashings. On tile roofs, it's usually cracked tiles and the mortar on the ridge and hip caps. Most of these are straightforward to fix if they're caught early. Left too long, the timber underneath goes soft and the steel rusts through, and repairs stop adding much life to the roof.

Why do old metal roofs start leaking all at once?

Until around 1980, metal roofs in New Zealand were usually fixed down with lead-head nails: a smooth steel nail with a cast lead head that seals against the roofing. The NZ Metal Roof and Wall Cladding Code of Practice notes that lead heads often backed out and caused leaks. Here's how that happens.

A building moves. Timber and steel expand and contract with every change in temperature, and over the years the nails work themselves loose. Once a nail has lifted, there's a small gap between the underside of the head and the roofing. When it rains and the wind blows, the sheet is pushed down, the gap opens up, and water runs down the nail into the timber below.

That water softens the timber around the nail, and over time it starts to rot. A nail in soft timber holds very little, so the fixings around it take more of the load, and they start to loosen too. That's why the problem compounds so quickly.

We often hear something like: “I've lived here 20 years and never had a problem. Now there are leaks all over the place.” The roof was fine until it wasn't. By the time leaks show up in several places at once, the damage underneath has usually been building for years. Here's what happens if rot is found when the roof comes off.

Rust around old nail heads along a flashing on an older Hillcrest roof
Hillcrest: rust around old nail heads along a flashing. Each one is a place water can follow the nail into the timber.
Old corrugate roof sheets lifting at the laps where the lead-head nails had popped, Remuera
Remuera: old sheets lifting at the laps where the lead-head nails had popped, letting wind-driven rain in under the roofing. See the Remuera job.

Why lead heads cause problems even when they stay put

Lead and the steel roofing are different metals. The Code of Practice says lead isn't compatible with modern metallic coatings, and on older roofs we often find the rust starting in the iron around a lead head.

That makes replacing the nails harder than it sounds. Pull a nail out of rusty iron with a hammer and you can tear the sheet. Put a screw into a hole where the steel has already rusted and the screw can pull straight through, making the problem worse.

When does re-screwing or painting stop being worth it?

There's a fine line between maintenance done early enough to extend a roof's life and maintenance done so late that it only buys time.

Replacing lead-head nails with screws and sealing washers is worth doing while the timber is sound and the steel around each hole is still in good condition. Once the timber under the fixings has gone soft and the sheet around them has rusted, a new screw has nothing solid to hold. At that point, in our experience, re-screwing adds very little.

The same goes for paint and coatings. Painting a metal roof that's still in reasonable condition can extend its life. Painting a roof that has gone decades without maintenance, with rusted sheets and loose nails, generally won't. Rust converter doesn't always stop rust that has set in, paint doesn't hold well on a surface in poor condition, and in time it flakes away. Some roof coatings are sold with long warranties, but a coating only protects the surface. It doesn't fix loose fixings, soft timber or failed flashings, so it doesn't change how the roof performs.

If you're not sure which side of that line your roof is on, a roof inspection will tell you. If it's past repairing, here's what a reroof costs in Auckland.

Heavy rust across an old roof face on a Mount Eden villa, looking out towards the street
Mount Eden: heavy rust across an old roof. At this stage, new fixings or a coat of paint won't add much life.

Rust under the ridge and other flashings

Flashings are the folded metal pieces that cover the joins in a roof: the ridge along the top, barge flashings at the gable ends, apron flashings against walls, and back tray flashings behind penetrations.

Where a flashing sits on the roofing, moisture can get trapped between the two surfaces, and the steel underneath corrodes where nobody can see it. One leak we see often is at the top of the roof. The tops of the sheets under the ridge have rusted, and in a storm the wind blows rain up under the edge of the ridge flashing and in through the rusted sheet ends.

The fix is to take the ridge off, cut back the rust, turn up the ends of the sheets so water can't get past them, and fit a wider ridge flashing. Whether that works depends on how far the rust has spread. Sometimes it does, and sometimes there isn't enough sound steel left.

Fixings in the wrong place cause leaks too. If a nail or screw has gone through the soft edge of a ridge flashing, water can drip through the gap between the two.

Sealant smeared over the joins in an old ridge flashing on a Hillcrest roof
Hillcrest: sealant smeared over the ridge joins. Sunlight breaks this kind of patch down, and it doesn't fix the rust underneath. See the Hillcrest job.

Pipe flashings and other penetrations

Every pipe, flue and vent that goes through a roof needs a flashing. On metal roofs that's usually a rubber boot, often called a Dektite or Aquaseal, sealed and riveted to the roofing. Over time the rubber and the sealant around it break down.

Many older roofs also have no back tray flashing behind the penetration. Without one, water running down the roof hits the boot and sits in the pans of the roofing behind it. We often find someone has been up and run silicone around the back of the boot, but sunlight breaks that down too.

The fix we use:

  1. Remove the old boot.
  2. Fit a back tray flashing behind the penetration, running up to the ridge or up under the flashing above.
  3. Fit a new boot on the diagonal, in a diamond shape, so water hitting it runs off the sides instead of sitting along a flat top edge.

A back tray matters for another reason. If a pipe has gone through a sheet lap, water travelling inside the lap runs down, hits the pipe and gets inside. A back tray catches it. We recommend a back tray flashing behind every penetration, whatever its size. The Code of Practice also says a boot shouldn't restrict the flow of water: if it blocks more than half a pan, other options should be considered.

A patch of newer sheeting and a pipe flashing on an old Mount Eden roof, with rust along the laps
Mount Eden: a pipe flashing in a patch of newer sheeting, with rust along the laps around it.

Water tracking back at the bottom of wide-pan roofing

On wide trough profiles, and concealed-fix roofing with flat pans, the bottom ends of the pans should be turned down into the gutter. If they aren't, water can cling to the underside of the sheet and track back up under the roofing instead of dropping into the gutter. The Code of Practice requires turn-downs on low-pitched roofs, and we recommend them on any wide-pan roof.

Copper, moss and lichen

Some things speed up rust on a steel roof:

  • Copper. Copper pipes on a steel roof, or water running off copper onto it, cause corrosion. The Code of Practice says contact with copper, or run-off from it, must be avoided on steel roofs.
  • Moss and lichen. They hold moisture against the steel like a sponge, so the roof underneath rusts out faster. The Code of Practice also notes that lichen roots may get into the paint and cause permanent damage, so it's worth treating early.
Lichen on an edge flashing and rust around an old nail head, Hillcrest
Hillcrest: lichen on the edge flashing, and rust starting around an old nail head.

Internal gutters and membranes

Internal gutters sit inside the roof line rather than hanging off the edge. Steel internal gutters can hold a lot of water, and they tend to corrode faster than the rest of the roof. Older membrane gutters, such as Butynol, tend to fail at the joins or peel away from the surface underneath. When an internal gutter leaks, the water goes straight into the building.

A rusted steel internal gutter beside the roofing on a commercial building in Glenfield
Glenfield: a rusted steel internal gutter on a commercial roof. See the Glenfield job.

Pressed steel tiles

Pressed steel tiles, such as Decramastic, have problems of their own. They're strong at the nose but weak in the middle, so a foot in the wrong place dents the tile and can open a small tear. Water pools in the dent and drips through the tear. The nails holding the tiles down also work loose over time, until the tiles move in the wind and leak at the side laps.

Decramastic-type tiles made from the late 1950s to the early 1980s can have asbestos in the coating, so get them tested before anyone works on the roof. Our asbestos roof removal page explains how removal works.

Worn and damaged pressed steel roof tiles in Milford
Milford: worn and damaged pressed steel tiles. See the Milford job.

Concrete and clay tiles

Concrete and clay are porous. Once the coating has worn, water soaks into the tile, and on cold nights it can freeze, expand and split the tile.

The other common leak is at the ridge and hips. The ridge and hip caps sit in mortar (the bedding), with a finishing layer over it (the pointing). Over time that cracks, and water runs in through the top. If it has no way out, it builds up and leaks inside.

Keeping a tile roof watertight usually means:

  • re-bedding and re-pointing the ridge and hip caps
  • replacing cracked or split tiles
  • a soft wash to clean the tiles
  • re-coating them to close the pores and protect the tile

There's more on tile maintenance in metal vs tile roofing in New Zealand conditions.

Weathered mortar and debris at a hip end on an old concrete tile roof in Westmere
Westmere: weathered mortar at a hip end, overdue for re-bedding and re-pointing. See the Westmere job.

Blocked valleys, gutters and spouting

Valleys and gutters carry a lot of water in heavy rain. When leaves and debris block them, the water backs up and can overflow under the roofing or into the house. Keep them clear, especially under trees. If new spouting overflows even when it's clean, the cause is usually the layout or the fall. We've explained that in why your new spouting overflows in heavy rain.

A gutter full of debris and moss beside a window on a Hillcrest home
Hillcrest: a gutter full of debris, with moss growing along it.

Is it a leak, or condensation?

Not every drip comes from outside. Warm, moist air from inside the house can condense on the underside of the roofing and drip onto the ceiling, even when it hasn't rained. If marks appear after clear, cold nights rather than storms, condensation is a likely cause. We've written about it in why your roof needs to breathe.

Questions to ask a roofer about a leak

  1. Where exactly is the water getting in, and how did you find it?
  2. Is this a one-off, or a sign of a wider problem?
  3. Is the timber under the fixings still sound?
  4. Will new screws hold, or has the steel around the holes rusted?
  5. Does this penetration need a back tray flashing?
  6. How much life will this repair add, compared with replacing the roof?

If you'd like us to look at a leak, see our roof leak repair page.

Common questions

What is the most common cause of roof leaks?
On older metal roofs, in our experience, it's the fixings and flashings: lead-head nails working loose, rust under flashings, and failed pipe flashings. On tile roofs, it's usually cracked tiles and cracked mortar on the ridge and hip caps.

Why is my old roof suddenly leaking in several places?
Usually because the damage has been building for years. As nails work loose and water softens the timber around them, the fixings nearby take more load and loosen too, so once leaks start they spread quickly.

Can I just replace the nails with screws?
While the timber and steel are still sound, yes, and it's worth doing. Once the timber has gone soft or the steel around the holes has rusted, new screws have little to hold and add little life to the roof.

Will painting my roof stop it leaking?
Not on its own. Painting can extend the life of a roof that's in reasonable condition, but it doesn't fix loose fixings, rusted sheets or failed flashings.

How do you fix a leaking pipe flashing?
Remove the old rubber boot, fit a back tray flashing behind the penetration, and fit a new boot on the diagonal so water runs off the sides. Silicone over an old boot usually doesn't last.

Why does my ceiling get wet when it hasn't rained?
It may be condensation rather than a leak: moist air from inside the house condensing on the underside of the roof.

Sources: lead-head nails from the NZ Metal Roof and Wall Cladding Code of Practice section on fasteners; lead and copper compatibility from its durability section; lichen from its section on biological corrosion; turn-downs from its pre-installation section; pipe flashings from its section on boot flashings.

Technically reviewed by Impact Roofing Solutions.

This article is general roofing information based on our experience working on Auckland properties. Every building and roofing system is different, and requirements can vary depending on the existing construction, location, product specification and proposed work. Project-specific requirements should be confirmed before work begins.

Roofing guides

Planning a roof replacement?

Seven guides, in the order most people need them.

Start here
Roof replacement cost calculator
Enter your floor area, roof type and access for a planning range in under a minute. A guide, not a quote.
1. What will it cost?
What does a reroof actually cost in Auckland?
Typical ranges, what's in them, and what moves the price.
2. Tiles or metal?
Metal vs tile roofing in New Zealand conditions
The upkeep each roof needs, and what a tile-to-metal conversion involves.
3. Do I need a building consent?
Most reroofs don't need a building consent. So who checks the work?
What the Building Code still requires, and the questions to ask instead.
4. What should the quote say?
What should a roofing quote include?
What a good quote contains, with a comparison sheet to download.
5. Why are my quotes so far apart?
Why do roofing quotes vary so much?
What each quote may be leaving out, and what to compare instead of the totals.
6. What if they find rot?
What happens if they find rot when your roof comes off?
How hidden timber damage is found, priced and approved.
7. What am I covered for afterwards?
Workmanship warranty vs defects liability period: what's the difference?
How the two differ. Our own terms are on the warranties page.

Get in touch

Enquire Now